| Date | Time | Opponent | Score | Stats |
|---|
|
|---|
| 11/04/11 | 3:00 PM | | h | Grace Bible (Mich.) | W | 81-78 | | Tot |
| 11/05/11 | 3:00 PM | | h | Bellevue (Neb.) | W | 100-93 | | Tot |
| 11/09/11 | 7:00 PM | | h | Union (Ky.) | W | 94-70 | | Tot |
| 11/11/11 | 8:00 PM | | h | Cornerstone (Mich.) | W | 91-89 | | Tot |
| 11/12/11 | 3:00 PM | | h | Aquinas (Mich.) | W | 74-63 | | Tot |
| 11/14/11 | 7:00 PM | | h | Ohio Christian | W | 86-63 | | Tot |
| 11/22/11 | 7:00 PM | * | h | Marian (Ind.) | W | 75-58 | | Tot |
| 11/29/11 | 8:00 PM | * | a | Grace (Ind.) | W | 65-55 | | Tot |
| 12/03/11 | 3:00 PM | * | a | Mount Vernon Nazarene | W | 60-55 | | Tot |
| 12/07/11 | 7:00 PM | | a | Indiana East | | 76-79 | L | Tot |
| 12/10/11 | 4:00 PM | | a | Shawnee State (Ohio) | | 61-65 | L | Tot |
| 12/15/11 | 4:00 PM | | a | Saint Xavier (Ill.) | | 58-71 | L | Tot |
| 12/17/11 | 5:00 PM | | a | Trinity Christian (Ill.) | W | 79-61 | | Tot |
| 12/29/11 | 6:00 PM | | a | Grace Bible (Mich.) | W | 70-62 | | Tot |
| 12/30/11 | 8:00 PM | | a | Hope College Men | | 66-70 | L | Tot |
| 01/03/12 | 7:00 PM | * | h | Huntington (Ind.) | | 76-84 | L | Tot |
| 01/05/12 | 7:00 PM | * | a | Spring Arbor (Mich.) | | 64-70 | L | Tot |
| 01/07/12 | 3:00 PM | * | h | Goshen (Ind.) | W | 85-78 | | Tot |
| 01/10/12 | 7:00 PM | * | a | Taylor (Ind.) | | 68-71 | L | Tot |
| 01/14/12 | 3:00 PM | * | h | Bethel (Ind.) | | 80-83 | L | Tot |
| 01/17/12 | 7:00 PM | * | a | Saint Francis (Ind.) | W | 75-68 | | Tot |
| 01/21/12 | 5:35 PM | * | a | Marian (Ind.) | | 63-68 | L | Tot |
| 01/24/12 | 7:00 PM | * | h | Grace (Ind.) | W | 82-74 | | Tot |
| 01/28/12 | 3:00 PM | * | h | Mount Vernon Nazarene | W | 90-85 | | Tot |
| 01/31/12 | 7:00 PM | * | a | Huntington (Ind.) | W | 80-78 | | Tot |
| 02/04/12 | 3:00 PM | * | h | Spring Arbor (Mich.) | W | 57-48 | | Tot |
| 02/07/12 | 7:00 PM | * | h | Saint Francis (Ind.) | W | 72-70 | | Tot |
| 02/11/12 | 3:00 PM | * | a | Bethel (Ind.) | W | 94-87 | | Tot |
| 02/14/12 | 7:00 PM | * | h | Taylor (Ind.) | | 66-77 | L | Tot |
| 02/18/12 | 3:00 PM | * | a | Goshen (Ind.) | W | 75-74 | | Tot |
| 02/22/12 | 7:00 PM | | h | Goshen (Ind.) | W | 74-66 | | Tot |
| 02/25/12 | 3:00 PM | | h | Saint Francis (Ind.) | | 65-78 | L | Tot |
| 03/07/12 | 12:00 PM | | h | Warner Pacific (Ore.) | | 76-79 | L | Tot |
Note:
* denotes a conference game
f denotes a forfeited game
